HireBest and Topgrading

Two HireBest facilitators leading a structured hiring workshop

Where they agree

Both start from the same conviction: define the role before you interview, gather evidence against that definition and compare candidates against the role rather than each other.

HireBest grew from the same tradition. If you like Topgrading, you will love HireBest: it puts that discipline into software that the whole interview team uses on every role.

Where they differ

HireBest's own view, offered as a starting point rather than a verdict. Topgrading is a published methodology and we encourage you to read it yourself.

AreaTopgradingHireBest

What it is

A hiring methodology published as books and training

A published methodology (Cipher), training and software that runs it

The written standard

The Job Scorecard, written by the hiring manager

The Cipher—Charge, Outcome, Deliverables and Efforts—drafted from the job description and reviewed by the team

During the interview

Structured interview guides applied by the interviewer

Guides on screen with live transcription, coverage tracking and real-time coaching

Collecting ratings

Interviewers score against the scorecard

A forced four-point scale with a written rationale, submitted independently

The debrief

A structured discussion

Independent ratings side by side, plus grounded answers from the transcripts

Consistency across a team

Depends on training and discipline

The product carries the same Cipher, guides and scale to every interviewer

Where the gap shows

If hiring volume is low and one disciplined person owns every search, a book and template may be enough. If hiring is spread across managers and the fifth interviewer on the eleventh role must run the same process as the first, that is the problem HireBest is built for.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between HireBest and Topgrading?

Topgrading publishes books, training and an implementation method using Job Scorecards and structured chronological interviews. HireBest combines its Cipher method with software that drafts the standard, guides the interview and requires independent evidence-based ratings (as at September 2026).

Is HireBest a Topgrading alternative?

Both define the role before interviewing and gather evidence against it. HireBest adds software designed to apply the same standard for every interviewer on every role (as at September 2026).

We already use scorecards. Why change?

If scorecards are written for every role, reviewed by the team and rated independently with written evidence, you are already doing the important part. HireBest keeps that process consistent across roles.

Do I need to read the Cipher book to use HireBest?

No, but it explains the reasoning behind the framework. The Foundations course covers the same ground on video.

Sources

Competitor information checked 28 September 2026. Products change; confirm current capabilities directly with Topgrading.

Implement Topgrading methods

Topgrading workshop

See the difference on one of your roles

Bring a live requisition and we will build its Cipher in the session.

Request a demo How HireBest fits